pedantic /pɪˈdæntɪk/

My post on the word paralipsis came about as a result of my describing someone as being paraliptic. Someone told me, authoritatively, that I was in error and that paraliptic was not a word. I explained that it was a perfectly legitimate adjective derived from the noun, paralipsis, and then replacing the suffix by the -tic.

Not wanting to be proven wrong, my critic then said that if it were a word, why couldn’t she find in using a “dictionary site, wikipedia or any other references.” I countered by telling her that a word’s absence from an Internet dictionary doesn’t mean it is bogus – and I pointed her in the direction of the 2nd Edition OED, Volume XI, page 193, third column.

Her final comment was to accuse me of  “pedanticism and pretentiousness.” I took that as a victory.

Pendantic

Pendantic

But that made me curious about the word, pedantic, and whether it is a good or a bad thing. As far as I was concerned, all I was trying to do was support my hypothesis that paraliptic is a legitimate world, but she perceived it as pendantry. So, at what point is pedantry different from scholastic rigor?

A pedant was originally used for a teacher or schoolmaster, derived from the Italian pedante. Although there is no direct evidence, it is assumed that this, in turn, comes from the medieval Latin pedagogare meaning “to teach.” Hence the word pedagogue, which means “teacher.”

In the 15th century, being a pedant was OK. Starting in the 16th century, it took on a new meaning to apply to someone who “overrates book-learning or technical knowledge, or displays it unduly or unseasonably…one who lays excessive stress upon trifling details of knowledge or upon strict adherence to formal rules.”

This presumably includes people who pore over the OED simply to prove they are right. I guess I am a pedant after all!

Now, what’s this pretentious word all about…?

Advertisements

1 Comment

Filed under Etymology

One response to “pedantic /pɪˈdæntɪk/

  1. TG

    it is often assumed that longer form of words evolved from the shorter forms…

    however, it is also assumed that Latins never borrowed a word from languages other than Greek

    in Hebrew pedantic is a corrupted composite of – Pe (a mouth/speak) Dan (judgement) Taka (stick), meaning to say something that is irrefutable, or to make a final point in the argument that is usually found within the process of arriving at a judgement

    the greeks also borrowed this imperfectly in their claim to the source of the pedant with the ancient Greek Paidós (child, kid) – misunderstood borrowing of Pe Daat (Da’as) – speak knowledge, a paraphrasing of English expression “from mouth of babes”, meaning a well known truth, again, an irrefutable fact…the essence of being pedantic

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s